Platform Access vs. Usage Fees
Strategic Fee Structures for Platform Businesses
Hello everyone! Today I want to talk about something very important for people who run platform businesses - how you charge your customers.
Garvit Sahdev enjoys understanding the ideas that shape our world. The Thoughtful Tangle is an initiative to share this journey and experience with friends who love to do the same. He selects one idea and dives deep into it to understand its basics, relevance, impact, and opportunities around it.
Platform businesses connect different groups of people. Think about shopping malls connecting shoppers with stores, or apps like Uber connecting drivers with passengers. These platforms make money in two main ways:
Access fees: Charging people to join or stay on the platform
Usage fees: Charging people when they use the platform to do something
Getting your fee structure right is just as important as deciding how much to charge. It's like choosing between asking friends to chip in for a pizza party upfront or asking them to pay based on how many slices they eat. Both can work, but in different situations!
Let's explore when to use each type of fee and how to combine them.
Access Fees: Controlling the Gate
Access fees are like entry tickets to a club. You pay to get in, whether you use everything inside or not.
When Entry Fees Make Sense
Access fees work best when:
You offer something valuable just by being part of the platform
You have something special that people can't get elsewhere
You want to focus on serious users who are willing to pay upfront
Building Stable Revenue Through Access
The great thing about access fees is that they give you steady, predictable income. When businesses know how much money is coming in each month, they can plan better.
Usage Fees: Capturing Transactional Value
Usage fees are like paying per ride at an amusement park instead of a day pass. You only pay when you use something.
The Pay-Per-Interaction Model
With usage fees, you're charging people based on what they do on your platform:
Each booking made
Each transaction completed
Each message sent
Each item sold
When Usage Fees Work Best
Usage fees are great when:
Platform value comes from specific actions or transactions
You want to align your earnings with actual platform activity
You want to lower the barrier to entry (no upfront costs)
How Usage Fees Shape Behavior
Interestingly, how you structure usage fees can encourage or discourage certain behaviors on your platform. For example, charging sellers a fee per item listed might make them more selective about what they list.
Hybrid Models: Combining Access and Usage
Many successful platforms don't choose between access and usage fees - they use both!
Creating Balanced Fee Structures
A hybrid approach means charging some combination of:
A smaller access fee to join
Ongoing usage fees based on activity
This gives platforms some guaranteed income while also allowing them to earn more when there's more activity.
Industry Patterns
Different industries tend to favor different mixes:
Software platforms often use subscription access fees plus extra charges for premium features
Payment platforms might have a monthly fee plus per-transaction charges
Marketplaces might charge sellers a listing fee plus a percentage of sales
Shopping malls use a classic hybrid model:
Access fee: Stores pay base rent just to have a space in the mall
Usage fee: Many malls also take a percentage of each store's sales
This way, the mall has steady income from rent, but also benefits when stores do well. And stores share some risk with the mall owner - if sales are slow, they pay less overall.
Practical Considerations
Monitoring Costs and Implementation Challenges
Before choosing a fee structure, think about:
How easy will it be to track usage?
How much will it cost to collect and process payments?
Will customers understand how they're being charged?
Sometimes a simpler fee structure works better, even if it's not perfectly aligned with value, just because it's easier to manage.
Market Standards and Competitive Positioning
Look at what other similar platforms charge. If everyone in your industry charges a 15% commission on sales, charging 30% might drive people away, even if your platform is better!
Evolving Fee Structures as Platforms Mature
Your fee structure shouldn't be set in stone. As your platform grows, you might need to adjust:
Early stage: Lower fees to attract users
Growth stage: Adjust fees based on which user groups are harder to attract
Mature stage: Optimize fees to maximize profit while keeping users happy
Many successful platforms started with very different fee structures than they have today.
Conclusion
Designing Your Optimal Fee Structure
To find the right fee structure for your platform:
Know where your value comes from: Is it access to your network, or facilitating transactions?
Understand your costs: Fixed costs might suggest access fees, while variable costs align better with usage fees
Consider your users: Which side of your platform is more price-sensitive?
Start simple: Begin with a straightforward fee structure you can explain easily
Test and learn: Be ready to adjust based on how users respond
When and How to Adjust Fee Structures
Changing fee structures can be tricky because people don't like price increases. Some tips for making changes:
Add new features or value before raising prices
Give plenty of advance notice
Explain clearly why changes are happening
Consider creating different tiers instead of a single price increase
Remember, the best fee structure helps your platform grow by being fair to all users while generating enough revenue to keep improving your service.
The right fee structure isn't just about how much money you make today - it's about building a platform that can grow and succeed for years to come. Whether you choose access fees, usage fees, or a combination of both, make sure your approach matches what your users value and how they want to pay for it.
What fee structure is your platform using? Is it working well, or might a different approach work better? These are questions worth revisiting regularly as your business evolves.
Thanks for reading The Thoughtful Tangle! Subscribe to continue reading deeply researched stories about the interesting concepts that shape our world. ❤️